Shutter - Buy from Amazon: Theatrical Edition, Unrated Edition, or Blu-ray
The latest in a long line of
remakes of
horror films from Asia. This trend has been going for a while, but most of the recent entrants have bombed at the box office and with critics. This film is no different.
Shutter stars Joshua Jackson, whose post-Dawson's Creek career has not gone particularly well. In this movie is stars as Benjamin Shaw, a photographer who is taking his new wife to Japan with him for his new job. His wife, Jane, has difficulties adjusting to a new land, and things get worse after a car accident, and then she begins to see ghosts in photographs. However, if she being haunted, does it have something to do with Ben's previous trip to Japan, or is she just going insane?
Fans of horror films, especially those from Asia, will find nothing new with this remake, even if they have never seen the Thai original. Additionally, the execution is only mixed, at best. For horror, there are no real scares and the film never rises above mildly spooky. By the time we get to the big reveal in the end, it was too late as the film didn't hold my attention any longer. I don't think the movie is as bad as its Tomatometer score, but that's not saying much and there's very little here to recommend it.
On the other hand, the extras are better than expected given the film's short theatrical run. Things start with an audio commentary track with Rachael Taylor, who plays Jane the wife, as well as production executive Alex Sundell and screenwriter Luke Dawson. It's a good track and they provide more than enough information to be worth listening to. However, it's not a very deep look at the movie. Next up is an 8-minute featurette called Ghost in the Lens, which deals with the Japanese superstitions about ghosts. Ghosts are not as big of a part of Western society, although they certainly are those who believe in them, so this helps bridge the cultural divide in the movie. Speaking of which, the next featurette is called A Cultural Divide: Shooting in Japan, and it is exactly what it sounds like. There is also a nearly 10 minute interview with the director, a 6-minute interview with the screenwriter, and then a trio of featurettes that pretend spirit photography is real and not a result of pareidolia. Actually, more strangely, two of the featurettes pretend it's real, the other shows you how to fake it with photoshop. Finally, there are close to a dozen deleted and alternate scenes, some of which are mentioned in the audio commentary track. In total they run 14 minutes, but there's not much here.
As for the Unrated label, it is pure marketing. Sure, there are a few minutes of additional scenes (which are mentioned during the audio commentary), but there's nothing here that would lift the rating beyond the original PG-13
Additionally, I don't have the Blu-ray, so I can't say what differences there are in the versions. Given the more than 50% increase in price, there better be a lot. However, I don't think there are any additional extras.
Shutter is not the first remake of an Asian horror film, nor will it be the last. That said, given its reviews and its box office struggles, perhaps it should be. It is not a terrible movie, but there's almost nothing here that hasn't been done before, and hasn't been done better. The extras are better than expected, but both the two DVDs and the Blu-ray are not really worth a rental.