Comedy Central Presents - Uncensored - Volume II - Buy from Amazon
Another eight
stand-up comics doing a half hour act. I vastly prefer getting single comics for two main reasons. Firstly, 20 minutes is not enough to get into the heart of an act, most of which run closer to an hour. And secondly, because comedy is way too selective for a best of set to work. While there is no way to fix the first problem on a weekly half-hour TV series, they second is a bigger issue. I'm not expecting a perfect record, but the "Best Of" label should mean something.
When it comes to best of sets like this, my cut off point is 50%. I should enjoy at least 50% of the stand-up comics featured on the DVD enough to want to go out and buy some of their solo DVDs (if available). If that's the case, then I can recommend it to others. Of the eight here, I know of three of them: Dave Attell, Zach Galifianakis, and Patton Oswalt. And I'm fans of all three of them, so as long as they live up to the usual standards, I would only need one of the other five comics to recommend the DVD as a whole. Sadly that didn't happen. First of all, Dave Attell's material was a little weaker than usual, at least it's weaker than I remember it. Additionally, none of the rest really wowed me, but most had at least a few good jokes here and there. On the other hand, I've seen this Zach Galifianakis routine before and I laughed the first time I saw it, and laughed this time as well. And the same goes for Patton Oswalt. This is an early routine for Mike Birbiglia, and you can tell, as it is not as polished as it should be. Frank Caliendo's imitations are entertaining, for a little bit, but the grow tiresome fast. Stephen Lynch brings some musical comedy, which is a genre as old as humor itself. I like musical comedy, but only in smaller doses and before the set is over I'm looking for something more. Nick Swardson has some good material, like "Babies = Small Drunk People" but it starts off too slowly, especially since he's given only 20 minutes for his routine. Finally there's Daniel Tosh... who I don't remember at all. I watched the DVD the day before writing this, and I can't remember a single joke of his. Not a positive sign.
I would give full marks to Zach Galifianakis and Patton Oswalt, and give Dave Attell half credit, but I would not got out of my way to find more of the rest's work on DVD. Perhaps if you really like musical comedy, especially Stephen Lynch's brand, you could add another full point, and then overall it would reach the 50% ratio I'm looking for, but only if you round up.
There are no real extras on the DVD, as I don't count Comedy Central Quickies as extras, because they are just ads for unrelated programs.
Again proving that there is no such thing as "Best Of", Comedy Central Presents Volume II is worth checking out, but rent it and save your money for No Reason to Complain and Live at the Purple Onion and hopefully Insomniacs will get full season DVD releases soon.