Grey's Anatomy - The Complete Fourth Season - Buy from Amazon: DVD or Blu-ray
I'm starting to think the behind the scenes drama is more interesting than the stuff they actually film. This year,
Katherine Heigl's role on the show was cut back to accommodate her movie schedule, which was a nice gesture on the part of the producers, but then she complained not enough happened with her character. It got so bad that some thought she was trying to get fired from the show so she could pursue her movie career without breaking her contract.
As for the on the screen drama, the season starts off where last year ended, with Dr. Cristina Yang's wedding ending poorly, Dr. George O'Malley failing his intern exam and having to start over from the beginning, and of course there's a whole new batch of interns that the freshly minted residents need to train up. As for this season, we have an estranged family returning, promotions and the jealousy that comes with that, and a lot of romance, including a lesbian relationship, which was likely a result of the behind-the-scenes controversy last year. The series needed to bounce back from Season Three, but I'm not sure that it did. I am willing to cut it some slack, as the writers' strike did disrupt the plan for the season. Perhaps if they didn't have this interruption in their schedule, then they could have been enough to bounce back all the way.
On a side note, I was eating at my computer while watching the end of episode 9, Crash Into Me: Part 1 (it's the two-parter with Seth Green). I won't say what happens in that episode, but I will say it helped my stick to my diet. Also from that episode, if I were doing surgery on a white supremacist, I would fix him up, but I would given him stitches in the shape of a star of David. Because that would be funny.
Extras on the DVD include audio commentary tracks on three episodes and they have a mixture of cast and crew (including newcomers, Chyler Leigh, on the season premiere, and Lauren Stamile, on Forever Young). The rest of the extras are on the final disc, starting with an eight-minute featurette on the three new cast members. Next up is a six-minute featurette on McDreamy and McSteamy. The cast and crew spend 14 minutes talking about their favorite scenes. There are also just over a dozen deleted and extended scenes from a handful of episodes, but most are quite short and in total they run just under 12 minutes. There are also four and a half minutes of outtakes, and a recap of the first three seasons, which should be on disc one.
As for the Blu-ray, it has all of the extras above, and it is the first HDTV on Blu-ray to feature the SeasonPlay. I love SeasonPlay. It keeps track of where you are in the season so if you turn off the show, turn off the machine, start watching a new disc, etc., and then come back, it will tell you what disc, what episode, and how far into that episode you left off. However cool that may be, that's it in terms of extras, and it costs nearly 80% more. Additionally, while it looks and sounds great, it is not the kind of show you pop into your Blu-ray player to show off to your friends. It's just the nature of the show.
Additionally, my DVD screener came with a promotional DVD with the pilot episodes for three shows. The Blu-ray screener did not. This further hurts the argument that it is worth upgrading to High Definition.
The fourth season of Grey's Anatomy was an improvement over season three, but it is arguably still weaker than seasons one and two. Additionally, this is a strike-shortened season, yet the DVD costs the same as last year's full-season release, while the Blu-ray costs nearly 80% more. That said, fans of the show will still want to pick it up, while those interested in the developing HDTV on Blu-ray market might want to check it out.