Dalmatians Triple Shot - Buy from Amazon: 101 Dalmatians 2: Patch's London Adventure, 101 Dalmatians, and 102 Dalmatians
Disney is releasing three
101 Dalmatians related titles this week, including the
direct-to-DVD animated sequel, the
live action remake, and the
sequel to the
live action remake. Pretty much everything but the original.
101 Dalmatians 2: Patch's London Adventure - Buy from Amazon
Patch, one of the 99 Dalmatian puppies is depressed. He can't seem to stand out amongst his brothers and sisters and always seems to be pushed back to the rear of the crowd. So while the gang prepared to move to the country, he runs away to London, and runs into his hero, Thunderbolt, the famous TV dog. In the meantime, Cruella De Vil is back on the streets and in an attempt to cure herself of her obsession with the Dalmatian puppies, she become obsessed with an artist... an artist who paints black dots on white canvases. This will end poorly.
A direct-to-DVD sequel to a Disney animated classic. I've lost track of how many such movies there have been. I bet there are very few people at Disney that know exactly how many such films have been released. Granted, this one is better than average compared to the rest of these films, but it is still a far cry from the original. Additionally, there is only one new extra on this version of the DVD compared to the original release, a game called Patch's Twilight Adventure. In this game, you must solve puzzles, travel around a map, play a few mini-games, and collect keys to save your brothers and sisters. This is actually a lot better than most DVD games are and should entertain the kids as they play it a couple of times. And with the other two games, two music videos, and a making-of featurette, the DVD doesn't feel barren, but it doesn't feel worthy of upgrading either.
101 Dalmatians - Buy from Amazon
While making direct-to-DVD sequels to a Disney animated classics is common place, turning them into a live action remake is not. There have been a few updates to the story, including making Roger a computer programmer instead of a songwriter, and Cruella De Vil is the head of a fashion design empire instead of a... I'm not sure what she was in the original. However, while these changes are rather minor, there is a major change. In this version we focus more on the humans, and less on the dogs.
Granted, the movie has an impressive cast, including Glenn Close as Cruella De Vil, and plenty of British actors in smaller parts (Hugh Laurie, Tim McInnerny, Mark Williams, and others). But the dogs should be the stars of the show. Without hearing the voices of the animals, or at least the inner voices of the animals, the film loses a lot of its effectiveness, as they don't have real personalities. I think the filmmakers were assuming Glenn Close performance as Cruella De Vil would be enough, but it wasn't.
Additionally, there are no special features on this DVD.
102 Dalmatians - Buy from Amazon
While 101 Dalmatians earned poor reviews, it earned a bundle at the box office and a sequel was inevitable. This time we follow Oddball, the daughter of one of the original 101 Dalmatians, who is born without spots, and Waddlesworth, a parrot who is convinced he is a rottweiler. However, again the star is Glenn Close as Cruella De Vil, who starts the movie in a mental hospital being cured of her obsession with fur coats and paroled. However, the ringing of Big Ben somehow reverses the cure, and she again begins her mad quest to get a Dalmatian puppy fur coat.
If 101 Dalmatians was an unnecessary remake of a classic, this movie is an equally unnecessary sequel. It's not bad per se, but there's little here that sets it apart from the original, which wasn't very good to begin with. The limits its appeal dramatically.
Strangely, while the movie earned barely half of what the original made, this DVD is loaded with extras, especially compared to the original's DVD. Things start with an audio commentary track with the director and several of the animal trainers. There are also three behind-the-scenes featurettes on Cruella De Vil, the animals in the movie, and the sets and costumes. They can be watched separately, or together as an 18-minute featurette. There are four scenes you can watch with various levels of computer special effects. Adults won't learn a lot, but it could be fun for kids. There's a minute-long deleted scene, with optional audio commentary. A short montage with the puppies and finally a featurette on how to choose the right dog, which basically says nothing more than check with a local expert.
Of the three 101 Dalmatians-related films Disney is releasing on DVD this week, it is hard to be enthusiastic about any of them. 101 Dalmatians 2: Patch's London Adventure is arguably the best, but there's little reason to grab this movie over the original, and little reason to grab this DVD over the original release. The weakest of the three movies, 102 Dalmatians, has the best DVD, but I would only check out the live action films if you liked the original, but didn't like hearing the animals talk. I think it is safe to assume there are not many people like that out there.