Warning: This Blu-ray does not come out this week and makes its home market debut on the 2nd of December. However, the Blu-ray screener arrived early and I was able to get the review done this week.
The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian - Blu-ray - Buy from Amazon
Two quick notes. One, I actually got a review done early. That hasn't happened in a long time. Two, I only have the Blu-ray at the moment, but I expect to review the DVD for next week.
The movie starts with a woman giving birth in a castle, and shortly after an older man rushes in and helps the young Prince escape before troops are sent in to kill him. Shortly after, we return to England to the four children (Susan, Peter, Edmund, and Lucy). It's been a year since they've returned from Narnia, and some have not adjusted very well from being kings and queens to being school children. But they are soon called back to Narnia, only to discover that hundreds of years have passed since they were there last. Now the creatures of Narnia have been driven nearly to the point of extinction by the forces of Telmarine, of which Prince Caspian is the rightful heir.
The original film earned excellent reviews and became one of the biggest hits of 2005, so there was a lot of pressure on this film. For the most part it does live up to its predecessor, at least critically. (At the box office, it was another story.) It shares some of the same strengths, and some of the same flaws, but it is hard to imagine many people who enjoyed the first movie who will be turned off by this one. Conversely, if you didn't like the first movie, there's little to change your mind here. I did like how Susan's character is a little more proactive in the movie, but the film as a whole didn't have as much emotional strength. On a side note, and I admit I'm being picky here, there was a shot when the forces of Narnia were traveling underground during the final climatic battle where there was one shot with effects that were bad enough to take me out of the movie. It was a very short shot (I figure less than a second) and I am very anal about these things. There were a few other times where I thought, "That could have be worked on a bit." But that is unavoidable.
Moving onto the Blu-ray presentation, it looks and sounds fantastic. This is one of the best-looking live action Blu-ray releases I've seen. This is not surprising since when it comes to new releases, Dinsey is arguably the best studio out there. (I have had issue with some of their catalogue releases, on the other hand.)
Extras on the first disc are limited to an audio commentary track with the director and the five main actors (Anna Popplewell, William Moseley, Skandar Keynes, Georgie Henley, and Ben Barnes). They enthusiastically give plenty of information and maintain a high level of entertainment. The only other extra on the first disc is Circle-Vision Interactive, a 360 degree look at the sets complete with text, images, behind-the-scenes video, and some clips from the movie with audio commentary track. There's a lot of stuff to go through and it takes a long time to get through it all. But fans of the movie will want to do just that. Also, the Blu-ray is BD-Live enabled.
Over on Disc Two, there are a huge number of featurettes starting with Inside Narnia: The Adventure Returns, a 35-minute long making-of featurette; Sets of Narnia: A Classic Comes to Life, a 24-minute long featurette on the locations where this movie was shot; Big Movie Comes to a Small Town, a 23-minute long featurette on the town of Bovec where one of the climatic scenes was shot. Previsualizing Narnia is just over 10 minutes and deals with the previsualizing process, which is like animated storyboards done in rough computer animation. Talking Animals and Walking Trees: The Magical World of Narnia runs 5 minutes long and is about the creatures in the movie. Secrets of the Duel is a three-minute featurette on the fight between Peter and King Miraz. There are also two featurettes on becoming Trumpkin and Nikabrik. Finally, there are 12 minutes of deleted scenes, with intros, and three minutes of outtakes.
Finally, disc three has the digital copy for portable devices.
The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian was a very good movie, but not a great movie. It is worth checking out, but it doesn't feel like a classic of the genre and I have doubts that the franchise can survive much longer. That said, the Blu-ray has more than enough here that it is worth picking up, and since it is only $2 more than the DVD, there's little doubt which format is the better deal.