Warning: This Blu-ray does not come out this week and makes its home market debut on the 9th of December. However, the Blu-ray screener arrived early and I was able to get the review done this week.
Lost - Season Four - Buy from Amazon: DVD or Blu-ray
Yes, this review is a week early, but it is somewhat incomplete, as I only have the Blu-ray. Hopefully the DVD will arrive in time for next week.
This is season four of what I thought was going to be a five-year run, but during the extras, the creators mention season six. One of us is confused, and I hope it's me, otherwise we are in a lot of trouble. This is a hard TV series to review, because the show is so intricate, it is very, very hard to get into any real details without spoiling anything. All I can do is compare the show to previous seasons in vague generalities. I guess the most specific area I can talk about are the Flash Forwards, which are new this year. Instead of giving up more background information on the people stuck on the island, most of which has been heavily fleshed out already, these bits give us a look at several of the characters' futures. And since there are times where it is hard to figure out if it is a Flashback or a Flash Forward right away, there are some great gotcha moments here.
This season was shortened by the strike, coming in at just 13 episodes (or 14 if you count the double-length season finale), but the studio has compensated by adding additional extras. Things start with a recap of the three seasons done in 8 minutes and 15 seconds. It goes without saying there are spoilers to be found here. (Duh.) The rest of the extras are found on disc five, mostly in the form of featurettes. Lost on Location is an 8-part, 42-minute behind-the-scenes look at several location shoots for season four starting with... well, that would be a spoiler, wouldn't it. The Island Backlot: Lost in Hawaii runs 18 minutes and talks about the many locations in Hawaii where the show has been filmed. The Right to Bear Arms clocks in at 11 minutes and is about all of the guns found on the island. And there are a lot. Soundtrack of Survival is a 26-minute featurettes score for the show, the person who composes it, and the orchestra that performs its. Next up is 3 minutes of outtakes and 9 minutes of deleted scenes. The Oceanic Six - A Conspiracy of Lies runs 21 minutes and is a mockumentary on the cover story given by the six survivors from season four. The Freighter Folk, which is the latest new group found on the island. For people marooned on an island, they sure do meet a lot of new people. Offshore Shoot talks about the shooting on the freighter where a lot of the action takes place. There are also more than a dozen Mobisodes that run a combined 31 minutes.
The only Blu-ray Exclusive is Course of the Future: The Definitive, Interactive Flash Forwards. This starts with a game where you have to place a few of the Flash Forward clips in the right order, and when you do, you get to see all of them in Chronological order. Or you can watch only the ones pertaining to a single character.
Additionally, the Blu-ray looks and sounds amazing. I can't compare it to the DVD, at least not yet, but it is one of the best I've seen. It would be hard to imagine the Blu-ray is not a serious step up from the DVD.
As a TV series, Lost got off to an incredible start and quickly became must-see TV. And while every once and I while I think to myself, "Maybe they don't have a plan, and they are just winging it," I still think the quality of the show has held up well. In fact, season four is arguably better than season three. And even with a strike shortened run, it is worth picking up, while the Blu-ray is the better deal over the DVD.
Lower Learning - Buy from Amazon
A raunchy lowbrow comedy set in school. But it's not college, or even high school, but elementary school. What were they thinking? I've only seen a couple of reviews and they were both negative. Incredibly negative. Maybe if you are a disgruntled elementary school teacher this is worth checking out, but even then you have better options. Skip it.
Meals on DVD - Shop, Watch, Cook! - Buy from Amazon: Cozy Comfort Foods, Easy Chicken Dinner, Elegant Entertaining, Festive Turkey Dinner, Great Dessert Recipes from Paula Deen, Holiday Cookies, Mac and Cheese Feasts, Pasta from Gilda, Quick Meatloaf Recipes, Slow Cooker Recipes from Paula Deen, and Soul Soothing Soups
I like this concept. The idea here is to sell these DVDs at grocery stores near the isle where the key ingredient for the recipe is. However, I'm waiting for the screeners to arrive before passing final judgement.
Metalocalypse - Season 2 - Buy from Amazon
If you ever wanted to know what would happen if Brendon Small from Home Movies formed a death metal band, then this is the perfect show for you. Actually, this is a great show for fans of most Adult Swim or of Rock'n'Roll comedies like Spinal Tap. Extras include a bunch of clips, music videos, etc., all hidden as Easter eggs. Happy hunting. Certainly worth picking up for fans of the show, and if you haven't seen it yet, check it out, but start with Season One.
Mythbusters - Big Blasts Collection - Buy from Amazon
I love this show, but I greatly prefer full season sets to best of DVDs like this.
Perry Mason - The Third Season - Volume 2 - Buy from Amazon
Raymond Burr returns as the titular character in this quintessential courtroom drama. This is an amazing show, but I don't like how it has been treated on DVD with zero extras and split-season releases.
The Rape of Europa - Collector's Edition - Buy from Amazon
The regular edition DVD came out in September, and that's an unacceptably short period of time between releases.
Saturday Night Live - The Complete Fourth Season - Buy from Amazon
This was a rather stable season for the long-running show with no new cast members in the main cast (although Don Novello, a.k.a., Father Guido Sarducci made his debut as a recurring member). On the other hand, it was the last season with John Belushi and Dan Aykroyd. If you've been collecting the series so far, there's no reason to stop now, however, some might stop with season four giving season five a miss. Some of the highlights in terms of guest stars include Steve Martin, Michael Palin, Eric Idle, and others. Also, this is the season with Milton Berle, who was one of the worst hosts for the regular cast to work with; in fact, he was so bad this episode was banned from syndication. Ouch. Extras on the seven-disc set include three interviews from the era that run a total of 12 minutes. Not much to see here. However, it is still worth picking up for fans of the show.
Step Brothers - Buy from Amazon: Theatrical Version, Single-Disc Unrated Edition, Two-Disc Unrated Edition with Digital Copy, or 2-Disc Unrated Blu-ray
The re-teaming of Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly after the critical and financial success of Talladega Nights seemed like a no brainer. However, the pair of Middle-aged pre-adolescents didn't bring the same level of funny this time around. It is still worth checking out for most, picking up for many, but it is not as funny, nor does it have the replay value of their earlier film. As for which edition to grab, the Theatrical Version is not worth it, even though the R-rated version is arguably funnier than the Unrated version. However, all three other releases contain both the rated and unrated versions, so that is not an issue. The Single-Disc Unrated Edition has a number of extras including a singing commentary, deleted scenes, alternate scenes, and more. The Two-Disc Unrated Edition with Digital Copy as that, and even more deleted / extended / alternate scenes, and two making on featurettes including one on the music. Over on the 2-Disc Unrated Blu-ray, you will find all of that, plus the ability to remix one of the music videos, and it is BD-Live enabled so you can, among other things, share your creation with others. Quite a lot to be found here. The 2-Disc Unrated Blu-ray is the best deal at just $2 more that the equivalent DVD.
Warning: This Blu-ray does not come out this week and made its home market debut on the 19th of November. However, the Blu-ray screener arrived late, hence the delay in this review.
Tropic Thunder - Blu-ray - Unrated Blu-ray
This will just be a quick update from the previous review where I only had the Unrated DVD to review. Now that the Unrated Blu-ray has arrived, I can describe the differences between the two formats.
The video and audio quality of the movie is great. It's a huge step up from the DVD, which wasn't terrible to begin with. Some of the jungle scenes are so good that you will want to pop this disc in your player to show off your home theater system. Others, like the scene with Jack Black tied half-naked to a tree are not so good. It's not that that scene had and technical problems, I just don't think anyone needs to see a half-naked Jack Black in High Definition.
Moving onto the extras, all of the extras from the Unrated DVD are here, mostly in High Definition. (Just the MTV bits are not.) The Unrated Blu-ray is also BD-Live enabled, which means if you have a Profile 2.0 player and a high speed internet connection, you can download several addition clips from Dispatches from Madness the mockumentary about the making of the movie within a movie and more Full Mags, which are the improv bits filmed for the movie that were later cut down to their best two or three lines. As a minor point, it is nice to get all of the extras on one disc.
This is arguably Ben Stiller's best directing effort and the Unrated DVD was an easy recommendation. I am pleased to say the Unrated Blu-ray is even better than expected and it is easily worth the extra $4 in price.
TV on DVD - Full Series Megasets - Buy from Amazon: None
No full series Megasets this week, but that changes next week.
Wanted - Buy from Amazon: Single-Disc DVD, Two-Disc Special Edition, Limited Edition DVD Gift Set, Blu-ray, or Limited Edition Blu-ray Gift Set
Wow. Five versions of this movie are going on this week, including two versions on Blu-ray. Wanted started out faster than expected, but fell sharply on its way to $134 million domestically and close to $340 million worldwide, so it is no surprise that is one of the biggest selling releases this week and there are plenty of choices for fans. The choice comes down to the Two-Disc Special Edition or the Limited Edition DVD Gift Set if you are limited to DVD. Or the Blu-ray or the Limited Edition Blu-ray Gift Set if you have made the leap to High Definition. The extras on the DVDs include a series of featurettes on the making of the movie, including ones on the cast, the special effects, its comic book origins, etc., as well as alternative / extended scenes, an animated comic book, and more. The Blu-rays include some additional extras like Picture-in-Picture and it is BD-Live enabled. Add in the visual nature of the movie and it is definitely worth grabbing on high definition. The Gift Sets, on the other hand, only have a few physical extras, including some postcards and a collectable case, and it costs nearly $20 more. Not sure its worth the upgrade, unless you are a huge fan of the movie or of the director. (The latter is more likely as the film was good, but not great.) Either way, I think it's worth picking up over just renting.
White Dog - Buy from Amazon
The movie focuses on a dog that has a violent streak, one directed only at black people, and the trainer trying to reverse the training his previous white supremacist owner inflicted on the animal. Long considered one of the most controversial movies of all time, but mainly because people somehow misinterpreted the film and assumed it meant the exact opposite of what the director, Samuel Fuller, meant. (This is similar to the Hitchcock film Lifeboat in that regard.) The film never had a theatrical release, but it was shown on HBO a few times, and was released on DVD last year. Now it is getting the Criterion Touch, but the extras are light with just a featurette on the history of the movie, and of Samuel Fuller, and some essays and an image gallery. Still, worth checking out for most, picking up for many.
X-Files - I Want to Believe - Buy from Amazon: Single-Disc DVD, 3-Disc Special Edition with Digital Copy, or Blu-ray with Digital Copy
Weak reviews, even weaker opening, and a fast decline at the box office adding up to a $20 million, making this film one of the weakest wide releases of this past summer. On the other hand, it didn't cost much to make and did significantly better internationally, so if it can beat expectations on the home market, it might be able to recoup its costs eventually. As for its chances on the home market, all three versions coming out this week are better than expected with the Single-Disc DVD containing a number of extras starting with an audio commentary track, but also has deleted scenes, outtakes, a featurette on the special effects, another featurette on the green conscious production, and a music video. The 3-Disc Special Edition with Digital Copy has all of that, plus a feature-length making-of featurette and a digital copy of the movie. Finally, the Blu-ray with Digital Copy has all of the above extras, with the audio commentary track upgraded to a Picture-in-Picture track, plus it is BD-Live enabled. Also coming out tomorrow is the previous theatrical release, Fight the Future on Blu-ray, as well as a franchise Blu-ray Box Set. At just $40 for two movies, it appears to be the best deal.
- C.S.Strowbridge
Date posted: 2008-12-02