Doubt - Buy from Amazon: DVD or Blu-ray
This film earned
reviews that were only good, not up to the level one usually sees in the major Awards Season player, but that's exactly what it turned out to be with all four main cast members earning
nomination after
nomination after
nomination. It's an interesting dichotomy and one that was on my mind when I watched it.
The movie is set in 1964 in a Catholic school where there is a battle of wills between the old guard, Sister Aloysius, and the new priest, Father Flynn, who wants to modernize the church. He wants them to sing some secular songs in the Christmas pageant. He uses a ballpoint pen. He takes three lumps of sugar in his tea. But there's something more at work here, and when Sister James reports something unusual is up with one of her students, Sister Aloysius attacks. The rest of the film is a battle of wills between Sister Aloysius and Father Flynn over much more sinister allegations than whether "Frosty the Snowman" is an appropriate song for the Christmas pageant.
First of all, this movie is based on a play, and at times you can tell. In many scenes the film feels confined, which is a real restriction when on stage, and while the movie opens up a bit, you can still feel its origins. However, and this is important, that's my only real complaint. I found myself completely drawn into this movie the first time I watched it, and the second time I watched it with the audio commentary track, I found myself paying attention more to the movie than the to director who was talking. All four lead actors deserved their nominations, and quite frankly, as I said just before the Oscars were handed out, Meryl Streep should have won. In fact, all four leading actors could have won and I wouldn't have been too surprised. Okay, I would have been really surprised, as Amy Adams and Viola Davis were competing against each other, but either could have won and I would have been happy with that selection. While in a normal year, Philip Seymour Hoffman would have been one of the favorites to take home the hardware.
Although I will say that I don't think the ending is as ambiguous as some do. I agree with Sister Aloysius, if he wasn't guilty, the lie would not have worked. It reminds me of Mystic Rivier in that regard; when the cops lied about having evidence against Dave, he didn't confess, but instead gained confidence and turned the tables on his accusers. I think if Father Flynn was innocent, he would have done the same.
Moving onto the extras on the DVD, I don't have it yet. I might not get it, as Disney appears to be phasing out support for the format. At least when it comes to promoting it. I think this is a wise decision, as even dramas are selling 10% of their total units on Blu-ray, while if you are a professional critic and you have not made the leap to High Definition by now, perhaps reviewing movies is more of a hobby.
The Blu-ray has the audio commentary with the director / Screenwriter / Playwright, John Patrick Shanley. He's not overly energetic, but he does provide a lot of information on both the movie and the real life inspirations. Certainly worth listening too. The rest of the extras are featurettes starting with From Stage to Screen, a 19-minute making-of featurette that is composed of talking heads, clips from the movie, and behind-the-scenes footage. Next up is The Cast of Doubt, which is 14-minute interview with all four main cast members. Scoring Doubt runs four-and-a-half minutes and it is about how Howard Shore wrote the score. Finally there's Sisters of Charity, a six-and-a-half minute featurette on the real life nuns that inspired the movie. I don't believe any of these are exclusive to High Definition, but the film looks and sounds great, and only costs $5 more for Blu-ray, and that's a premium that is worth paying.
I would consider Doubt to be one of the more under-appreciated movies of the year, at least with the critics. It is better than its Tomatometer score would indicate, and it earned 78% positive reviews. The extras are good, but not overwhelming, and either the DVD or the Blu-ray is worth picking up. I would go with the latter if you have the choice.