Defiance - Buy from Amazon: DVD or Blu-ray
This movie came out at the end of 2008 in limited release and given that fact, it would not be inappropriate to assume the film was made to win awards. That didn't happen, although it did earn an
Oscar nomination. On the other hand, it did do somewhat better at the box office than
predicted. So it was with mixed expectations that I went into this movie.
The film takes place in Belarus during World War II and focuses on two Jewish brothers, Tuvia and Zus, whose parents are murdered by the local police. At first they hide in the forest thinking of ways they can survive, and take revenge, but as they gather with more and more survivors, their goals start to diverge. Tuvia wants to protect lives, including those non-Jews how are caught between the Nazis and them, while Zus wants revenge and is willing to kill to survive. They have to try to survive against Germans, starvation, disease, etc., all while trying to maintain their humanity.
The reviews for this film were mixed with a lot of critics saying it was competently made, but it doesn't rise to the level of its source material. It's emotionally powerful at times, but not as powerful as the real history. Perhaps the film could have used a more delicate touch, which would have enhanced the drama, but thanks to strong performances by the cast, the film is still worth checking out.
Extras on the DVD include an audio commentary track with the director, Edward Zwick, who holds his own on this solo track. Return to the Forest is a 26-minute long making-of featurette, Children of the Otriad talks about the real life events that were the basis of this movie, while Bielski Partisan Survivors is a 2-minute slideshow of some of the survivors saved by the Bielski brothers.
All these extras are included on the Blu-ray, and they are presented in High Definition. There is also a 7-minute featurette on the scoring of the movie. That's not a lot of exclusive material, nor does it push the technology, but it's better than nothing. Additionally, the video looks excellent, and it sounds great as well. It does cost 50% than the DVD, which is a tad high. I would be willing to pay 30% to 40%. Perhaps the video is strong enough to put it over the top, but it would be very close, even then.
Defiance didn't find the audience it deserved and it should be seen by more. I'm not entirely sure the movie has enough replay value to warrant purchasing over just renting, nor am I entirely sure that the Blu-ray is a better deal than the DVD. Regardless if you rent or buy the DVD or Blu-ray, the movie is worth watching.