A River Runs Through It - Blu-ray - Buy from Amazon
I saw a review describing this movie as one of the greatest fishing movies ever made. That seems like damning it with faint praise in two ways. Firstly, how many fishing movies can there be? Secondly, this really isn't a movie about fishing, it is a movie about family, using fishing as a metaphor.
The film starts out with the director, Robert Redford, speaking as the adult Norman Maclean about how in his family fishing and religion were one and the same. We then see Norman as a young boy (played by Joseph Gordon-Levitt) and how his Reverend father (Tom Skerritt) raised him and his younger brother, Paul, to revere fishing. Flash forward to just after World War I and Norman and Paul are young men who have a falling out resulting in the two men going in different directions. Norman goes off to university and becomes a teacher, while Paul becomes a drunk and a gambler. The meat of the movie takes place during their adults years and looks at the conflicting personalities / obvious bonds of these two men. Fly-fishing is one such bond,
This movie earned impressive reviews, but not so impressive that it can be considered one of the all-time greats. It earned three Oscar nominations, but only won for Best Cinematography, losing out for Best Score and Best Adapted Screenplay. The only result that surprises me looking back was Tom Skerritt being overlooked for Best Supporting Actor. In my mind, his performance was the best in the movie. (Although I've read others who think Brad Pitt was the best and others that say Craig Sheffer was the heart and soul of the movie.) Some of the film was a little too emotionally manipulative. There's a fine line between being emotional and emotionally manipulative, and for the most part the film avoids those pitfalls, but there are times it steps over. That said, for many, the cinematography alone is worth watching the movie. And it shines in High Definition, but we are getting ahead of ourselves. It is definitely a movie that should be seen by more people, and many who do will like it enough to want to own it.
The previous DVD release was ... Less than acceptable, especially for one being called a Deluxe Edition, and had no real extras on the DVD. What changes have been made for the Blu-ray? First of all, there is a making of featurette called Deep Currents: Making A River Runs Through It, which runs 30 minutes long and details the creation of the book, how Robert Redford gained the rights, and finally how they made the film. An excellent featurette with high replay value. The Blackfoot Challenge: Rescuing A River runs half as long and is about the Blackfoot River, which is in serious ecological danger, but there are a group who are trying to save it called The Blackfoot Challenge. There is a six-minute featurette on Fly-Fishing for beginners. (On a side note, I don't like 'Catch and Release.' I like 'If you catch it, you eat it.' If you have more fish than you can eat, stop fishing so much.) There are seventeen deleted scenes that have a total running time of just over 16 minutes, so there are not a lot here for each scene. Several are definitely worth checking out, on the other hand. Finally, there are four scenes of the Blackfoot River filmed in High Definition that you can watch with or without the score. It's like one of those Scenic Views Blu-rays that you can use to show off your system. Admittedly, they are beautiful scenes, but I'm not sure I'll watch any of the four scenes again. (Also, the disc is BD-Live enabled, but there are no exclusive extras online at the moment.) In addition to the extras on the disc, there is a booklet built into the Blu-ray case that has production notes, images, essays, etc. I'm a bit upset that there's no audio commentary track, but the extras we do get are stellar, for the most part.
As for the film's technical presentation... Wow, this movie looks amazing at times. The fishing scenes especially look amazing, and the Oscar-winning cinematography shines in this movie. There are scenes that look a little more average, but overall I'm very happy with the video. The audio is a little more on the average side, and I'm still waiting for a movie that really pushes my surround sound system.
A River Runs Through It's debut on Blu-ray is a little more expensive than I am willing to pay most catalogue Blu-ray releases are. In fact, it's about twice as expensive. (Generally, I'm only willing to pay $10 to $15 for shovelware.) However, it is not just a catalogue release, as there are extras that are exclusive to this DVD, and the extras are all presented in high definition and includes some that can only be done on Blu-ray. Because of that, the Blu-ray is worth picking up.