Warning: This Blu-ray does not come out this week and made its home market debut on the 1st. However, the screener arrived late, hence the delay in the review.
CSI - Season Nine - Buy from Amazon: DVD or Blu-ray
This was a season of massive chance for CSI with, as all fans of the show know, William L. Petersen leaving the show partway through. I'm not sure why exactly he did this, but I doubt it was a contract dispute, because not only was he one of the highest paid actors on TV at the time, he was also a producer of the show. What I can say for sure is the number of changes early on had a dramatic effect on the series, but did they improve the show? Or at the very least, will the show be able to survive?
The answer to the first question is no. I have nothing against Laurence Fishburne, but his introduction changed the dynamic of the show and he became a much larger focus of the show than Gil Grissom. Additionally, Lauren Lee Smith was also introduced this seasons, meaning they had to spend much of the season getting two new characters integrated into the ensemble cast, which proved too much at times. However, I believe this is just a temporary problem and that by season ten, things should be moving smoothly again. Call it a bump in the road, and not a shark jumping moment. At least not yet.
On a side note, this is why the Law & Order formula works better when it comes to the longevity of a series. Law & Order is all about the cases. Sure, the personalities of the cops and lawyers matter when it comes to chemistry, but we almost never learn anything about their personal lives. Because of this, characters can be switched out without disrupting the dynamic of the show. In fact, in the 20 years that show has been on the air, there have been more than two dozen major cast members for the six main characters (two cops, the cops' boss, two ADAs, and the District Attorney). If that show ventured into the private lives of the characters as much as CSI does, that show would have died a long time ago.
Extras on the six-disc set include featurettes on the new cast members, Crime Scene Initiation. Also on disc one is deleted scenes one episode and a picture-in-picture / interactive / branching track on one episode. Over on disc two we find... nothing. It's the only disc without any special features. Disc three has deleted scenes on one episodes and a pop-up trivia track on another, The Grave Shift, which was Dr. Raymond Langston first time for fieldwork, so it's a good show to give special attention to. Disc four has deleted scenes on one episode (Miscarriage of Justice); Interactive Investigation Mode on a second episode (Kill Me If You Can); and an audio commentary track on a third (Turn, Turn, Turn). Disc five has two featurettes starting with Rats in Space, which is about A Space Oddity, my favorite episode of the season, and not just for the reason Archie Kao mentions. (Although having Liz Vassey in a 'Star Trek' bikini is great.) I love the Lab Rats episodes, as the background characters are much more interesting than the A-Team group, and combined with the Star Trek references, this episode hits my geekiness as well. At close to 30 minutes, it's very in-depth. The next featurette is From Zero to 200 in Nine Seasons, which is about the 200th episodes. There are also deleted scenes and an audio commentary track on A Space Oddity, which just goes to show how much this episode means to the cast & crew. Disc six starts with deleted scenes on two episodes. There is also a featurette on the departure of Gil Grissom from the series. The set is also BD-Live enabled with some text-based information, as well as a trio of short video clips.
As for the technical aspects of the show, the video is good for TV release, but not up to the level of Lost, for instance, or what you would expect for a theatrical release. Audio was better with good use of the surround speakers. I'm happy with the technical presentation, but this is not a release I would grab to show off my home theater system. (TV on DVD rarely is.) The Blu-ray is the same price as the DVD, so it's a no-brainer which one is the better deal.
The massive amount of change that happened during season nine of CSI was arguably more than in any previous season of the show. Not arguably more, but obviously more. It was arguably more than all other previous changes combined. Because of that, the show a little weaker than in the past, but it is still worth checking out. Add in the impressive list of extras and season nine is worth picking up with the Blu-ray being the far superior choice over the DVD. Sadly, when it comes to TV on DVD, the High Definition release is usually overpriced, so it is nice to see that this is not the case here.