Ice Age - Dawn of the Dinosaurs - Buy from Amazon: DVD, DVD with Scrat Pack, or Blu-ray
First a note, I only have the... I don't know version of the movie. I got two DVD-R screeners from the studio, which might be the
DVD with Scrat Pack, but I really hope not, because if it is, the
DVD is a terrible release. But we are getting ahead of ourselves.
Ice Age - Dawn of the Dinosaurs starts off where The Meltdown ends, namely with Manny and Ellie expecting their first kid. Diego realizes he's out of shape, something he blames on being part of the herd, which has made him soft. With Manny and Ellie preoccupied and Diego planning on leaving, Sid feels left out and wants to start a family of his own. While contemplating the best way to do this, he stumbles into an ice cave and 'rescues' three eggs, which hatch rather quickly making Sid the proud mother of three baby Tyrannosaurus Rexes. Unable to control his kids, the destruction they cause it only limited because their real mother comes and takes them back, and in the process kidnaps Sid. Now it is up to Manny, Ellie, and Diego to travel to the lost world to rescue him, with the help of their guide in this new world, Buck.
Ice Age - Dawn of the Dinosaurs was the biggest hit from the franchise domestically and it set record after record internationally. However, after watching the movie my reaction to that is, 'Huh?' It's not a bad movie, per se, but it feels so very average. There are some improvements over the first two installments, including a cool new character and great animation scenes, but the story is just not as compelling. The action scenes started to feel repetitive, while none of the characters have much of an arc and the arcs they did have were not capitalized on very well. Diego wanting to strike out on his own and meeting Buck could have been really interesting; however, it was practically only used for a couple of jokes. Still, it is worth watching once for fans of digital animation, and if you have kids, they will likely want to watch it enough times that it is worth picking up.
Extras on the first disc include an audio commentary track with the directors, animators, producers, etc. ... and that's it. According to the press kit I got with the screener, this is all that's on the DVD, which is unacceptable for this type of release. This is absolutely only worth a rental.
The second disc is the 'Scrat Pack' portion of the DVD with Scrat Pack and it has a number of extras starting with a trio of short films featuring Scrat: Gone Nutty, No Time For Nuts, and The Sabre-Toothed Squirrel: Natures Nutty Buddy. I was never a big fan of this character, so keep that it mind when I call these shorts merely mediocre on average. I did like the time travel humor of No Time For Nuts, but I have no desire to watch the other two again. There are also two shorter live-action clips about the 'real life' discover of a sabre-toothed squirrel found frozen in the ice, but these are less successful than the animated shorts. There are a handful of making of featurettes starting with the fluffy Fox Movie Channel Present feature, as well as two focusing on two of the new characters, Buck and Scratte. Other minor extras include a music video, and an instructional video on how to draw Scrat. Overall this is a good selection of extras, but I can't imagine it really needed to be on two discs and it costs 50% more.
The Blu-ray does have some exclusives extras, but I won't know what those are for sure till it arrives. And it won't be shipped till Tuesday, so look for an update to this review next week. However, since it costs less than $1 more than the 2-disc set, and it includes all of the extras on the 2-disc set, there's no reason not to buy this one if you are interested in the movie.
Technically, Ice Age - Dawn of the Dinosaurs is easily the best of the franchise, but storywise it is the weakest. That said, there's more than enough here to entertain kids, even if their parents won't be quite as enthralled. If you are just interested in renting the movie, then the DVD is just fine. However, if you want extras, you'll need to grab the DVD with Scrat Pack, but the Blu-ray is by far the better deal.