The Incredible Hulk - Buy from Amazon: Single-Disc Edition, 3-Disc Collector's Edition, or Blu-ray
Just a quick note, I only have the
3-Disc Collector's Edition and I can't get into specifics with the
Single-Disc Edition or the
Blu-ray. I assume the former is just the first disc of the version I have, while the latter has a couple of BD-Live features, but we will get to that soon enough. First, to the movie itself.
When the original came out in 2003, it was hotly anticipated, which explains the film's $60 million opening weekend. However, while Ang Lee was ale to get some introspection out of the comic book tale, this is not what fans were looking for, which explains the film's then record-setting fall during its second weekend. Fans of the Super Hero don't want deep introspective, they want "Hulk smash!" This time around, they got "Hulk smash!" Granted, not everyone will think The Incredible Hulk is an improvement over the first film, and there are some issues with lack of character depth / development, as well as some technical issues (some have complained about the CG animation found within), but overall, those looking for a popcorn flick should be happy. Happy enough to await a third Hulk film? I'm not so sure about that, but he should be one of the selling points to The Avengers.
The 3-Disc Collector's Edition has plenty of extras spread over the first two discs (the third is a digital copy of the movie.) Things start with an audio commentary track featuring Louis Leterrier and Tim Roth. It’s a great track that is filled with information and nary a dead spot and the two men bounce a lot of information off of each other. There are also half-a-dozen deleted scenes running a grand total of 13 minutes, many of which could have been placed back into the movie, but were likely trimmed for pacing reasons. (I think Blu-rays should be able to seemlessly reincorporate trimmed footage like this back into the movie. I don't know of any that have done this, but I look forward to it becoming common place.)
Over on disc two, things start with an alternate opening, which is an interesting extra, but I prefer the opening they went with. More deleted scenes follow, 17 in total, running nearly 30 minutes. Many work, but are unnecessary. There is a 30-minute making-of featurette, which is worth checking out but pretty standard fair. I see so many of these each week, that it takes a lot for any of them to stand out. Becoming the Hulk is a 9-minute featurette on the design of the CG Hulk, as well as Edward Norton's preparation to perform as the comic book icon. Becoming the Abomination is a very similar featurette, just on the Abomination. Anatomy of a Hulk-Out is three smaller featurettes combined into a nearly 30 minute whole on the times that Bruce Banner turned into the Hulk in the movie. From Comic Book to Screen is a 6-minute semi-animated comic book.
The third disc is just the digital copy, which I'm a fan of. Even though I don't have a portable device to watch the movie on, I like the option.
The Incredible Hulk will not be seen as one of the best comic book movies of all time, but it is a fun ride and fans of the recent influx of similar titles should be entertained by the movie. As for the three home market releases, the 3-Disc Collector's Edition is certainly worth the upgrade from the Single-Disc Edition. Additionally, even if the Blu-ray had no additional features, it would be worth buying over the DVD. However, with a couple BD-Live extras, it is certainly worth paying $3 more for. Regardless of which format you decide to get, it is worth buying over just renting.