Battle for Terra - Buy from Amazon: DVD or Blu-ray
This film will go down as one of the biggest box office flops of all time. It opened in just over 1000 theaters, but finished with less than $2 million total. The only good news is its production budget, which is rumored to be in the mid-teens. $13 to $16 million isn't a lot to spend on a movie, but was it money well spent?
The film is set on a distant planet where a group of aliens live in treetop cities floating in the dense atmosphere. They are visited by a group of aliens that some mistake for their gods but are in fact invaders from Earth. It turns out that hundreds of years ago, humans used up much of the resources on Earth and spread to Venus and Mars. However, 200 years after that, Mars and Venus fought a war of independence from Earth, which ended up destroying all three planets. Now the remnants of the species are traveling through space looking for a planet they can land on. However, that planet is Terra, and it's occupied. This species includes Mala, an adventurous, inquisitive, and intellectual young lady. She's one of the first to see the human spaceship fly over the planet, and one of the first to see the attack ships come. And when her father is abducted, she takes on these invaders looking to be captured as well, but she manages to instead capture / rescue one of the humans, Jim Stanton. At first, Jim Stanton sees Mala as a monster, but when she saves his life, and helps him get back to his people, he sees her as a friend. However, the general in charge of the human military, General Hemmer, has a less open view of these aliens, and he feels the only way to save the human race, is to destroy Mala and her people.
This is not a bad movie and it has a lot going for it, including a story that has a little more to it than a simple story of good vs. evil. The invading humans are not simply genocidal maniacs; they are desperate for a new world and know that without one, they will die out. And Mala and her species are not innocents; they are a rather restrictive, dogmatic society that are led by an undemocratic group of 'Elders', who clearly are keeping something important from their people in order to control them. That said, there is not a lot here that's too memorable. The story can be a little predictable at times. The animation is smooth, but not detailed enough to match up well against most major theatrical releases. I think that's the biggest problem. People watching ads for this movie before it hit theaters would probably assumed it was a direct-to-DVD or TV movie, or at the very least, one aimed at kids alone. I don't think that's the case, and I think a lot more people should give it a try on the home market. The extras will determine whether or not it's worth picking up or just renting.
Extras on the DVD start with an audio commentary track with three of the crew who talk about the process of making the movie, which was based on a short film and was originally going to be a live action / CG massive blockbuster, not a small Indie film. There is a five-minute making of featurette that is typical for this type of film. It is worth checking out, but it is not as in-depth as I would like. There are four deleted scenes with a total running time of seven minutes, and quite frankly, I think they should have been kept in the movie. There is a very short clip shown in four different stages of animation: storyboard, animatic, Maya, and final. There's a longer, 2-minute clip shown in animatic and final version. There's a 90-second clip of an animated, puppet-like version of Aristomenis Tsirbas talking about his love of movies while walking through the sets.
I don't have the Blu-ray, but I there are no additionally extras. That said, at $19.99 is a great price for a Blu-ray, and digitally animated movies tend to pop on High Definition. If I get the Blu-ray to review later on, I will update the review with the technical specs.
Battle for Terra is not as bad as the reviews would indication, and it's much, much better than its box office performance would indicate. Both the DVD and the Blu-ray are worth checking out. Call it a solid rental, leaning toward a purchase.