Warning: This DVD does not come out this week and made its home market debut on the 17th. However, the DVD screener arrived late, hence the delay in this review.
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - A Very Sunny Christmas - Buy from Amazon: DVD or Blu-ray
The screener arrived one week late, at least the DVD screener arrived one week late. The Blu-ray is still M.I.A., and will likely stay that way.
For those who are now aware of the show, it follows the exploits of five people who refer to themselves as, 'The Gang' who run an Irish bar in Philadelphia called Paddy's Pub. The Gang consists of Dennis Reynolds and his twin sister Deandra "Sweet Dee" Reynolds, their 'father' Frank Reynolds, and their two friends, Mac and Charlie. None of the five are worth jack as human beings, nor do they possess any real talent or ambition, but that doesn't stop them for holding high opinions of themselves and coming up with elaborate schemes to get what they believe they are owed.
In this direct-to-DVD special, it's Christmas Eve and The Gang are trying to celebrate; however, this turns out to be harder than it would first appear, because their lives suck. Dennis and Deandra try to get back at Frank for all of the horrible things he's done to them at Christmas. It seems every year he finds out what they really, really want as a gift, and then buys it for himself, even if that gift is a designer purse. He claims it's to teach them the true meaning of Christmas, but it is more likely he's just a jerk. After learning his former partner, Eugene, whom Frank conned and stole his company from, is not dead, they decide to pull A Christmas Carol and get Eugene to dress up as a ghost and scare him, while they show him his past, present and future. Meanwhile, Mac and Charlie are having trouble finding the Christmas spirit as well, so they relive their past childhood memories, which turn out to not be as happy as they remember them. Will the Gang be able to find their Christmas spirit in time? Or is there at least enough alcohol in the bar to help them repress the memories they've uncovered this year?
Good news, bad news time. Good news, this is a very funny special episode of It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia. Bad news, it's basically a double-length episode of the show, with a few elements thrown in that they couldn't get away with, even on cable. Bad news, it's just a double-length episode, which means at roughly 44 minutes in length, there's not a lot of entertainment here for the price. If you are a fan of the show, and even if you haven't seen it before, it is certainly worth checking out. The parody of Rankin/Bass Stop-Motion animation Christmas specials like Rudolph, the Red-Nosed Reindeer make it worth checking out, but there's at least a 50/50 chance it will be included on the Season Five DVD release, which will undoubtedly be a better deal.
On a side note, this special is not rated, but it would earn an R-rating. Not only are there a lot of swear words in the special, including plenty of F-Bombs, but there's a scene where one of the Gang nearly shows full frontal nudity. And it's not Sweet Dee. Or Dennis. Or Mac or Charlie.
Extras on the DVD include a making of featurette, three deleted scenes, and a sing-along. At least it says sing-along. There are no lyrics displayed on the screens, while the visuals quickly take a turn for the bizarre. In total it's just thirteen and a half minutes of extras, which is not enough given the short running time of the main program.
I don't have the Blu-ray, but I do know that it is not in High Definition, since the show is not shot in High Definition, but merely an upconverted version of the original Standard Definition release. On the one hand, this will be greatly disappointing to people who spent the extra money for the Blu-ray. On the other hand, it is only $1 more, so at least it's not too much more. I'm actually hoping this catches on with some studios. Hear me out; I don't want this to be repeated, but something similar. Imagine being able to buy Blu-ray for a TV sitcom from before High Definition was common, like Cheers, for instance, and having a full season fit on one disc. Talk about saving a lot of shelf space. And since the price of one BD-50 has dropped dramatically, and thanks to the less packaging, lower shipping costs, etc., it might actually be cheaper in the stores. Of course, this could only happen once Blu-ray has overtaken DVD as the standard, and we are at least a few years away from that.
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - A Very Sunny Christmas is very funny and worth checking out. However, the show is too short and there are not enough extras on either the DVD or the Blu-ray to make it worth buying over just renting.